Comparison
Push vs electric golf trolley
Published
Note: This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more
In short
A push trolley is light, simple and never needs charging, and suits flatter courses and golfers happy to push their bag. An electric trolley does the pushing for you, which makes a real difference on hilly courses, with a heavy bag or over 36 holes, but it is heavier to lift into the boot and needs battery care. Choose by your course, your bag and how you feel at the 18th.
Clicgear
Clicgear 4.5: folds to 33 x 38 x 61 cm
Check price on AmazonAffiliate linkPowaKaddy
PowaKaddy FX3: lithium, 5 year UK battery warranty
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
- Clicgear 4.5: folds to 33 x 38 x 61 cm
- Folded size
- 33 x 38 x 61 cm (13 x 15 x 24 in)
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link - PowaKaddy FX3: lithium, 5 year UK battery warranty
- Folded size
- Not stated
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
| Product | Folded size | Link |
|---|---|---|
| Clicgear 4.5: folds to 33 x 38 x 61 cm | 33 x 38 x 61 cm (13 x 15 x 24 in) | Check price on AmazonAffiliate link |
| PowaKaddy FX3: lithium, 5 year UK battery warranty | Not stated | Check price on AmazonAffiliate link |
Details as stated in the Amazon listing or by the manufacturer. See the current price on Amazon.
Our verdict
Choose a push trolley such as the Clicgear 4.5 if your course is fairly flat, you carry a light bag and want something simple that folds small. Choose an electric trolley such as the PowaKaddy FX3 if your course is hilly, you play a lot or 36 holes, or you would rather save energy for your golf.
Most golfers who walk start with a push trolley and later wonder whether to go electric. The answer depends on your course, how often you play, what you carry and how much lifting you are happy to do in the car park. This comparison sets a premium push trolley against an electric one using listing facts, then looks at effort, boot space, battery care and electricity use so you can decide.
What each one does
A push trolley carries the bag on three wheels while you push it, with a brake to park and storage for a phone, drink and scorecard. An electric trolley adds a motor, a battery and a speed controller so it rolls along at your walking pace; you guide it rather than push it. Higher end electric models add downhill control, GPS screens or remote control.
Two models compared
The push trolley's advantages are clear: a stated compact fold and lots of storage. The electric trolley's listing focuses on the frame and battery warranty. Our push trolley guide and electric trolley guide cover more models.
| Feature | Clicgear 4.5 | PowaKaddy FX3 |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Push, three wheel | Electric, 18 hole lithium |
| Folded size | 13 x 15 x 24 in (33 x 38 x 61 cm) | Not stated |
| Weight | 7.26 kg (packaged) | Not stated |
| Brake | Front-wheel hand brake | Not stated |
| Extras | Console, phone holder, rangefinder magnet, umbrella holder | PowaFrame, height adjustable handle |
| Warranty | Not stated | 2 years trolley, 5 years battery (UK) |
Effort on a hilly course
On a flat parkland course, pushing a trolley is easy work for most golfers. On a hilly course, pushing a full bag up steep slopes for 18 holes is harder, and controlling it on the way down takes effort too. An electric trolley takes away the uphill push, and models with electronic downhill control hold a steady speed on the way down. If you often feel tired by the back nine, or play 36 holes in a day, electric makes a noticeable difference.
Bag weight matters as well. A full cart bag with waterproofs, umbrella, drinks and spare balls is heavy. If you like to carry everything, electric help is welcome; if you travel light, a push trolley is often enough.
Boot space and lifting
Electric trolleys are heavier and bulkier than push trolleys, especially with the battery, which is usually lifted out separately. If you have a small car or find lifting awkward, look closely at folded sizes and weights. Compact electric designs exist, but a compact push trolley is still the easiest to handle. Our folded sizes reference lists stated sizes.
Batteries, charging and electricity use
An electric trolley needs its lithium battery charged after each round and stored properly over winter. Batteries come in 18 and 36 hole sizes. Electricity use per charge is small: a battery's capacity in watt hours is its voltage multiplied by its amp hours, so a 24 V 10 Ah battery, like the one in a remote trolley in our electric guide, holds 240 Wh, which is 0.24 kWh. Charging losses add a little to that. Our battery guide covers charging and storage.
| Consideration | Push trolley | Electric trolley |
|---|---|---|
| Charging | None | After each round |
| Energy per full charge | None | Battery Wh plus losses, e.g. 0.24 kWh for 24 V 10 Ah |
| Winter care | Clean and dry | Clean, dry, store battery as maker advises |
| Parts that wear | Wheels, brake | Wheels, brake, battery, motor, electronics |
Club rules and winter
Many UK clubs restrict trolleys in wet winter conditions or require winter wheels, and some have different rules for electric trolleys. Check before you buy, especially if you play mostly in winter. Our winter wheels explainer covers this.
Note:Charge lithium trolley batteries with the maker's charger only, on a hard surface away from anything flammable, and do not use a damaged battery.
A middle path
If you are torn, consider how often each problem arises. If you only struggle on one or two steep holes, a light push trolley with a good brake may be enough. If you dread the walk every week, an electric trolley is likely to be used and appreciated. Some golfers keep a compact push trolley for quick evening nines and an electric one for weekend rounds.
Frequently asked questions
Is an electric trolley worth it for a flat course? Often not. A good push trolley is lighter, simpler and cheaper to run on a flat course.
How long does an electric trolley battery last per charge? Makers rate batteries for 18 or 36 holes. Hills, cold weather and bag weight reduce range.
Can I convert a push trolley to electric? Not practically. Choose the type you need from the start.
What you need
- Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
Clicgear 4.5: folds to 33 x 38 x 61 cm
From: Best push golf trolleys
- Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
PowaKaddy FX3: lithium, 5 year UK battery warranty
- Check price on AmazonAffiliate link
Clicgear Rovic RV1C 2.0: one touch fold